Friday, April 11, 2008

The Credit Score Scam

Most people think having a good credit score is necessary. This is the most successful marketing lie that exists in the financial industry. It only matters if you borrow money. Unfortunatey landlords, insurance companies, and various other companies have started using it as a guide. It is the lazy mans evaluation of a person's creditworthiness. Unfortunately, since there are so many errors on credit reports it has become an unreliable source of evaluating creditworthiness. Getting these errors corrected is a formidable task. While you are correcting them, more errors appear. It is a losing battle.

Despite what most people think, the credit bureaus don't work for consumers, they work for creditors. They will not accept any information from a consumer without undisputable proof, while the creditor just simply needs to make a claim and it is slapped onto your report unverified.

What's more, the scores themselves have now become a way to rip off consumers. There is the FICO Score (considered the standard), and then each credit bureau has their own proprietary score. They have started giving away "free" credit reports, which are little more than bait for subscriptions. The consumer thinks they are purchasing accurate information, when each bureau is likely to have vastly different information, and the score they give looks higher than the actual FICO score. There is a lawsuit in progress attempting to address this.

You even have to be careful about who you get your financial advice from. Suzy Orman is in bed with Fair Isaac and touts the value of a good credit score because she makes money when she does. However, Fair Isaac has recently settled a class action lawsuit against them involving Suzy Orman and her "FICO kit" for claims that they violated the federal Credit Repair Organizations Act and various state laws. They got away with providing "free" 3 to 6 month subscriptions. Ironic, since the FICO score marketing is all about improving your score, yet the scores continue to be fraught with countless errors, helping them continue to sell credit repair for their own mistakes.

The truth is that if you don't borrow money, the FICO score formula gives you a poor rating. In actuality, you are the lowest risk. Lenders who pay attention to what they are underwriting will see this. The score means little in the end with lenders who pay attention who they are lending to. As for the others, the landlords, the insurance companies, and employers. You can simply point out the errors and usually get past this screening. If you don't borrow money and tell them this is your policy, they should think highly of you regardless of the zero FICO score.

0 comments: